Select Page

Stevia: A Better Way to Sweeten

Got a sweet tooth?  You’re not alone.  Many of us (myself included!) have a weakness for the sweet stuff.  Here at Simple Organic, we’ve already looked at two options for healthier sweeteners: organic whole cane sugar and maple syrup/sugar.  Today, we’ll take a look at a third option: stevia.

Stevia is a natural sweetener.  It has been getting a lot of attention the past couple of years because it was recently approved by the FDA as a sugar-substitute in food and drink items. It’s popping up at mainstream groceries as an ingredient in sugar-substitutes such as PureVia (owned by Pepsi) and Truvia (owned by Coca-Cola).  However, many people in natural foods circles have been using stevia as a sweet herb for years.  I began using it in 2002, and it’s actually been around for ages.  So what’s the big deal about stevia?

Benefits of Stevia

Stevia is an herb that is native to South America.  The leaves of the stevia plant are intensely sweet, much sweeter than sugar.  And the great news for those who are watching their health is that stevia contains zero calories, zero carbs, and has zero glycemic index!  For someone like me, who has had to remove all sugars from their diet because of health issues, stevia sounds too good to be true!  However, there are a few caveats.

Drawbacks of Stevia

• Some people don’t like the taste of stevia; it can have a slightly bitter or licorice-like aftertaste.  Some flavors, such as citrus, will mask this aftertaste really well, but not every flavor is suited to this.

• It’s very hard to use in baked goods because you need so little of it to reach the same amount of sweetness that a larger amount of sugar would provide, so if your recipe needs the kind of “bulk” that sugar offers (as most baked goods do), then you can’t easily sub in stevia for sugar.

• In addition, I would not use stevia while pregnant, because its safety for babies in the womb hasn’t been conclusively determined.  In addition, I don’t let my young daughter use it, for similar reasons.

• Finally, stevia is on the expensive side.  That will likely change as it becomes more readily available, but for now it’s still produced in pretty small quantities.  Of course, since it’s an herb, you could always grow your own!  That’s something I intend to look into very soon.

Stevia in My Home

Personally, I use stevia primarily to sweeten beverages, such as a glass of iced tea, a cup of coffee, or homemade lemonade.  However, there are many recipes out there that do use stevia in all sorts of baked goods and desserts.  You can also purchase a stevia-sweetened baking blend that can be used as a substitute for sugar, but personally I have had a hard time with that; the stevia flavor is too strong for me and I don’t like the taste of the final product.

Stevia is available in many other forms, as well: liquid, powder, fiber-fortified powder, and even naturally flavored liquids such as vanilla, orange, and root beer.  Add a few drops to carbonated water and you have a natural sugar-free soda!  Yum!  This is one of my favorite ways to use stevia. My favorite brands are Sweet Leaf and NuNaturals.

Photo by Michael Fludkov

Important Note: The two brands of sugar-substitutes that I mentioned above, PureVia and Truvia, contain stevia as one of their ingredients. The other ingredient is erythritol, a sugar alcohol in the same family as xylitol and maltitol. I just wanted you to be aware that these two sweeteners are not 100% stevia. Always read ingredients!

Where to Find Stevia

More and more mainstream groceries are carrying stevia; just look in the sugar section or ask your grocer. Health food stores definitely have it, and it’s also available online.  You can find out everything you always wanted to know about stevia at They have recipes, articles, links to news stories, cooking tips, and more. Here is a yummy recipe for oatmeal apple muffins by Vicky Mosser, taken from Stevia Rebaudiana: Nature’s Sweet Secret by David Richard.

Oatmeal Apple Muffins

1 Cup Whole Wheat Flour
1 Cup Rolled Oats
1/2 tsp. Salt
3 tsp. Baking Powder
1/2 tsp. Nutmeg
2 tsp. Cinnamon
1 1/2 tsp. Stevia
1 Egg
3/4 Cup Milk
1/4 Cup Oil (or 1/4 Cup Applesauce)
1 Medium Apple Cored and Course Chopped
3/4 Cup Raisins

Preheat oven 400 degrees. Mix first seven ingredients thoroughly. In separate bowl mix remaining ingredients. Gradually mix dry ingredients into moist ingredients. Spoon into greased muffin tins. Bake 15 to 20 minutes.

Have you ever tried using stevia? Do you have tips or recipes that use stevia? Please share!

Reading Time:

3 minutes





  1. Kara

    I wish that I could like Stevia, but I just don’t. It doesn’t taste good. 🙁

    • Katie

      Try the liquid drops – they’re much better! Also, it’s better in some things than others.

      • Nicole aka Gidget

        I feel the same way about the taste, maybe I’ll try the liquid, too.

  2. Shannon

    I don’t eat sugars at all, so stevia is about my only sweetener. The best tasting brand I have found is NuNaturals. I use it in coffee, tea, whipped cream, and the occasional bowl of oats.

  3. Sandra Lee

    Doesn’t it also make a difference whether you use the processed stevia (white powder) vs. the more natural form – brown? I myself found the taste of stevia can vary a lot depending on the brand.

  4. Lisa@MomsGreen ShoppingList

    I never knew stevia was a sweetener. I don’t use a lot of sugar but I do put a lot of honey in my iced tea. Maybe I can get my husband to switch from the 2 sugars he uses in his coffee.
    Hopefully I can find it around here, things like that are always hard to find when you live in the backwoods. Maybe I’ll have to try growing my own also.

  5. Kim

    My mom uses Truvia, but I didn’t want to buy it because of the high price tag. So I decided to grow stevia in my garden. It did really well and it should come back next year. I dried the leaves and have been adding them to my tea instead of honey. I just steep them with the tea bad and then take it out. Thanks for the note about using it during pregnancy. I would assume it is safe, but I will check with my midwife.

  6. Mandy

    Have you tried the muffin recipe yourself? How did the muffins taste? And which form of stevia did you use, powder/liquid? Thanks!

    • Nicole aka Gidget

      I was wondering the same… powder or liquid? or does it matter?

    • Katie

      I used liquid drops when I made them because I like the liquid taste better – but I don’t see why powdered wouldn’t work! If someone makes them with powdered, let us know how it turns out!

  7. Stacy @Stacy Makes Cents

    I made these this week using the powdered Sweet Leaf. They are VERY good! Mine are extremely crumbly…not sure why? The taste makes up for it though.
    🙂 I’m very pleased with my first time baking with stevia. Thanks for the recipe! I passed it along on my Facebook page.

  8. Caroline S

    Well, I found Stevia extract too bitter. I found Truvia et al WAY too expensive so decided to take matters into my own hands. Armed with a calculator, I first of all purchased 16 oz Stevia extract with 90% Steviasoides. My aim was to produce a calibrated liquid extract that I could add to food and drink. I figured that my 1lb pack gave me the equivalent sweetening power of 350 lbs of sugar and worked from there.

    This is what I calculated.. add 10 grams of the above product (I have an inexpensive cooking scale that measures to 1 gram) to 700 ml water in a bottle or jar and shake well. Refrigerate. I obtained a kid’s 5ml medicine dropper calibrated into 1ml divisions for $1.00 and my calculations mean that 1ml of this liquid is equal to 1 teaspoon of sugar .. and yes it works! I have used it to make a spectacular organic walnut cheesecake, to sweeten iced tea, iced coffee, salad dressing.. I will keep a dropper bottleful in my purse for use when I’m away from home. I have also checked out research into health benefits and found that Stevia is used for treating diabetes, high blood pressure and heartburn; for lowering uric acid levels; and for increasing the strength of the muscle contractions that pump blood from the heart. Highly recommended!

Join thousands of readers
& get Tsh’s free weekly email called
5 Quick Things,

where she shares stuff she either created herself or loved from others. (It can be read in under a minute, pinky-swear.)

It's part of Tsh's popular newsletter called Books & Crannies, where she shares thoughts about the intersection of stories & travel, work & play, faith & questions, and more.